Today I am here to rant about the new
phenomenon that is Fifty Shades of Grey by E.L. James. BE WARNED: THE FOLLOWING
POST IS FULL OF OPINION. I AM IN NO WAY STATING NEITHER THAT I AM A GOOD WRITER
NOR THAT I HAVE GOOD TASTE IN BOOKS. After all, I did read the entire series of
Fifty Shades of Grey series. Sorry. Couldn't resist, mate. <---Insert
Captain Jack Sparrow skeletal face here. :)
VISUALLY AND CONCEPTUALLY:
First let me start off with my problem
with the book visually and conceptually. It is really deceptive looking book
series with a silver tie on the cover of the first book, a masquerade mask on
the second book, and a pair of handcuffs on the third installment. If you know
absolutely nothing about the series, which means that you've been living under
a rock at this point, you might be deceived into thinking that this is your
typical cool detective series. By the time you get to the third book, and
that's IF you get to the third book, and you know what the series is about, you
would probably roll your eyes. Here is why: The third installment of the series
is entitled "Fifty Shades Freed," (first of all...what? Is that even
a phrase?) and with the picture of the handcuffs on the cover, it's like it is
trying too hard to entice you into a mystery when really all the picture is
referring to is the main characters, fucking. That's what all the covers to the
books symbolize. Nothing more. It's about as deep as a puddle.
In addition, I have issues with the author
making her name E.L. James on the cover. She's trying to be androgynous so that
people will not dismiss her book as a poorly-written romance novel based on her
name. What she doesn't understand, is that we won't judge her and her writing
skills or the book based on her name. We will judge the book on the fact that
it IS actually very poorly written. Besides, once you get three sentences into
knowing the main female lead, you know that the author is female; so the point
is moot. I know J.K. Rowling did the same thing to her name for the Harry
Potter series. The difference is that since Harry Potter is a very well-written
male main character, I didn't even know probably until the third one that J.K.
was female...!
MAIN CHARACTERS:
ANASTASIA
STEELE
This name is horrible and arbitrary but
let's face it: if you read any other romance novels almost all of their
names are terrible and arbitrary. I wish to run a mad-libs-like experiment in
which I take three hats, put names of gems and old English authors in one
(Danielle, Anastasia, Bella, etc.), put colors and night-oriented creatures in
the next hat for last names (Wolfe, Night, Swan, Knight, Grey, Rose, etc), and
put euphemisms for the male genitals in the last hat (member, shaft, length,
etc.). I will select one from each hat at random and BAM! I will have the next
bestselling romance novel and I can guarantee you that it will be infinitely
better than Fifty Shades of Grey.
Anastasia Steele describes herself
critically at the beginning of the book as a plain sort of mousy girl with
brown hair and blue eyes. She compares herself to her roommate Kate whom
according to her is everything she is not. Strawberry-blonde, beautiful,
athletic, graceful, assertive, sexy and ambitious. At this point I am already
wondering why we aren't reading about Kate.
Anastasia Steele is 21 years old and is an
English Literature major about to graduate from college. She lives with Kate,
because Kate's family is well off, they gave her the place and Anastasia's
portion of the rent is cheap. Anastasia and Kate live in Forks... Woops. I mean
Portland. In her spare time, Anastasia (or Ana as she prefers it:
"Isabella Swan?" "Bella.") likes to read Jane Eyre, Jane
Austen and Emily Bronte and stay at home. She works part-time for a family
owned home improvement-like business and everybody loves her because she's just
so awkward and meek and somehow irresistible. Ana's mother is a scatter-brained
but lovable woman who has been married and divorced close to as many times as
J.Lo. Ana's step-father, Ray, is a man of little words who obsesses about
sports and fishing. Blah blah blah blah. Boring boring boring. My head is
already screaming Twilight, Twilight, Twilight...
CHRISTIAN GREY
Let's play the hat game again except for
the main male character. First hat has names that sound good enough to be
screamed out and/or whispered during sex (Christian, Jason, James, Tristan,
Edward, etc.). The second hat has colors and animals (Grey, Wolfe, Black,
etc.). The third hat has synonyms for vagina (sex, femininity, delicate folds,
sweet spot, etc.).
Christian Grey is described as a chiseled
Adonis man with "scorching" grey eyes (Christian Grey has grey eyes
how original) and copper hair. He is brooding and mysterious with a fierce
temper and a stalker-ish, overbearing, insanely jealous, and overprotective,
domineering, control freak, possessive personality. He has a
"harrowed" past that mars his ability to love and be loved and makes
him damaged and desirable. And he likes to fuck. A lot. Hard. And kinky. And
"spank the living shit out of" girls. Um...what?
Christian and his brother and sister were
all adopted by a wealthy family except this time Carlisle...ahem, I mean his
mother Grace, is the doctor. Christian is 28 years old and the CEO of his own
company who answers to no one and who makes "100,000 dollars an
hour." Every woman swoons over him and he is fully aware that he's pretty.
Somehow, however, he falls prey to only Anastasia's awkward and plain charms.
ADDITIONAL
Then there are the additional characters:
Jose Rodriguez, Jacob Black's Mexican counterpart who Ana is not attracted to
and too good for; Paul Clayton who is Ana's bosses son and plays the role of
Twilight's Mike (always asking her out and getting rejected and following her
around like a lost puppy); Jack Hyde, Ana's boss later on in the series who
sexually assaults her and then goes postal and tries to kill her and Christian.
Wait all these people want to sleep with
Ana so far... Let's try to remember that she's not pretty folks.
And background girls who are prettier than
Ana but jealous of her because she is so unexceptional and managed to land
Christian Grey and background guys who secretly want to fuck Ana because she's
just so...ugly.
GRAMMAR:
I am the Queen of missed commas. I reject
commas like nobody's business. I just don't know where they go an in fact, I'm
sure you realized this while reading this because I just can't seem to grasp
the concept of where to place commas in my writing. My grammar is horrible. My
vocabulary is okay but if my grammar were rated in an O.W.L. in Harry Potter, I
would get a "T." For TROLL.
That being said, you know the grammar in a
book is bad if even I can pick out mistakes. I have excellent reading
comprehension; that's where I scored the highest on my SATs and where I have
always scored the highest. So when I have to read a sentence three times over
in order to grasp the concept...IT IS POORLY WRITTEN.
PLOT:
I am genuinely saddened to report that
until the end of the second book there really IS NO PLOT. The "plot"
is Ana being unexceptional and undeserving of Christian and Christian being
inexplicably attracted to her. He wants to do kinky stuff to her and she's a
virgin so she's not sure about it blah blah blah. And then they have sex. A
LOT. Every chapter sometimes five times a chapter. Sometimes that IS the whole
chapter. They have poorly-written sex when they are happy, angry, sad, lonely,
hungry, crying, talking, celebrating, in danger, etc. They have sex on the
piano, on his bed, on her bed, in his room, in her room, on the couch, in his
kinky playroom, on the spanking couch, on the real couch, in the shower, on the
bathroom counter, in the car.... That is LITERALLY ALL IT IS until the end of
the second book where E.L. James suddenly switches into third person (after a
whole two books being in the first person present) to take on the form of Jack
Hyde, Ana's insane ex-boss who wants to fuck her and then kill her and
Christian and take all their money. That is E.L. James' half-hearted attempt to
a semblance of a plot. Throughout the series she makes her idea of mini-plot
detours (like Ana's father suddenly getting into an accident and falling into a
coma) because even SHE knows that the book is getting boring. I got to the
point that I actually groaned when Ana and Christian were going to have sex
again. And NOT in the good way. I put the book down several times just because
I couldn't deal with them "making the beast with two backs," as Ana
put it, CONSTANTLY. Seriously, Ana's vagina would realistically be as wide as
the Lincoln Tunnel if this was real life. Thankfully, this isn't because I
would hang myself. And that would make me more sexually hard core than anything
suggested in Fifty Shades of Grey.
BOTTOM LINE: "T" FOR TROLL
Don't read this book. Don't even look at
this book. Spare your eyes, your money and your brain cells because this book
and this series was just a complete waste of time that I used as a distraction
while I try to find a job. The only thing that came out of this is that I
laughed. A LOT. Because this book is embarrassing. Go buy a slice of pizza and
eat it slowly and that will be more sexually gratifying to you than Fifty
Shades of Grey will ever be.
You forget that it was written as a fan fiction to Twilight and the somebody told her she should publish it.
ReplyDeleteWhat bothers me is that drivel like that gets published but me, I'm a starving artist of the writing variety.